According to our Trust Barometer data from January, business is the most trusted of society鈥檚 four main institutions, after passing NGOs in 2021, and now is seen as twice as competent as government. Our new data from the 2024 黑料社Trust Barometer Special Report: Trust at Work shows that employers have a critical role as the most believable source of information 鈥 among employees across seven countries globally 鈥 and as an island of civility.
But today, companies are rebalancing their stakeholder priorities. While employees were the priority during the Covid-19 period, now companies are being pressed to pull back from DEI, sustainability, and other cultural commitments. And as the 2024 Trust at Work Special Report shows, there is a chasm emerging within the global workforce, jeopardizing everything from employee engagement to employer advocacy.
Our data reveals a stunning 32-point difference between executives and associates on their average level of trust in the major global institutions: business, government, media, and NGOs. This trust difference between job levels is over twice the mass-class trust divide between high- and low-income employees, which has spurred the rise of populism in politics.
Only 19 percent of associates trust their CEO to tell the truth about the organization, versus 52 percent of executives. There is deep fear of innovation, with only 22 percent of associates feeling that they have a lot of control over AI and its impact on their work. Associates, bruised by the pandemic, are almost half as likely to report very good or better mental health as executives (41 percent of associates vs. 75 percent of executives), with particularly low numbers among all employees in the UK (48 percent), Germany (42 percent), and Japan (25 percent).
The trust divide between executives and associates is inextricably linked to economic optimism, defined as believing that you and your family will be better off in five years. The economic optimism gap between executives and associates has metastasized in the past five years, according to our January Trust Barometer data, from 26 points to 39 points (78 percent of executives felt economically optimistic in January of 2024 vs. 39 percent of associates), as associates鈥 confidence plunged 10 points since January 2019 while executives鈥 stayed relatively steady over that same period.
This belief in a better future is a critical engine of employee engagement. When employees have the sense of agency, impact, and sustainable employment that drives economic optimism, they will put in greater discretionary effort, be better advocates to would-be recruits, and show greater enthusiasm for innovation. A more optimistic workplace can also knit together the social fabric, as data from recent Trust Barometers shows that employees with economic optimism are more willing to make personal sacrifices for the greater good of the country (78 percent vs. 54 percent of those who do not have economic optimism; January 2023), and more confident the country can work through ideological divisions (52 percent vs. 27 percent without economic optimism; January 2024).
Here are five recommendations for CEOs hoping to close the trust and economic optimism gaps:
Employers are the key to the trust puzzle. When workers know there is a path to a better life, they invest more in their work. They invest more in their employer. And they invest more in their country.
Richard 黑料社is the CEO.